Sums of three cubes

Hall of records

Seven decades of x3 + y3 + z3 = k, from a question about 3 to the seven numbers nobody has cracked. Every triple below checks in your browser, digit for digit.

9 triples to check7 still openThe Ponmath era

  1. 1953

    Louis J. Mordell

    A question about 3

    Mordell writes that, about 3, he knows only the two small answers, 13 + 13 + 13 and the one below, and asks whether there are more. The answer takes until 2019.

    x
    4
    y
    4
    z
    −5
    Post on X
  2. 1955

    J. C. P. Miller and M. F. C. Woollett

    The first computer search

    Miller and Woollett put Mordell's question to EDSAC, an early computer at Cambridge, and widen it to every positive k up to 100. Their 1955 paper starts a long line of machine searches.

  3. 2009
  4. 2016

    Sander Huisman

    74 falls

    Huisman pushes the search out to 1015 and finds the first answer for 74.

    x
    −284650292555885
    y
    66229832190556
    z
    283450105697727
    Post on X
  5. 2019

    Andrew Booker

    33 falls

    Booker turns the search around, so its cost grows with the smallest of the three numbers instead of the largest, and finds 33. He also rules out every other open k below 1000 up to |z| ≤ 1016. Ponmath's search is built on the same idea.

    x
    8866128975287528
    y
    −8778405442862239
    z
    −2736111468807040
    Post on X
  6. 2019

    Andrew Booker

    795 falls

    The same search settles 795.

    x
    −14219049725358227
    y
    14197965759741571
    z
    2337348783323923
    Post on X
  7. 2019

    Andrew Booker and Andrew Sutherland · September

    42 falls

    The last open number below 100. About 1.3 million hours of computing on Charity Engine, a grid of volunteer PCs, searching every open k below 1000 out to 1017.

    x
    −80538738812075974
    y
    80435758145817515
    z
    12602123297335631
    Post on X
  8. 2019

    Booker and Sutherland · September

    165 falls

    The same Charity Engine run.

    x
    −385495523231271884
    y
    383344975542639445
    z
    98422560467622814
    Post on X
  9. 2019

    Booker and Sutherland · September

    906 falls

    The same run again.

    x
    −74924259395610397
    y
    72054089679353378
    z
    35961979615356503
    Post on X
  10. 2019

    Booker and Sutherland

    A third way to write 3

    A further search of about 4 million computer hours on Charity Engine answers Mordell's question of 1953. The largest number has 21 digits.

    x
    569936821221962380720
    y
    −569936821113563493509
    z
    −472715493453327032
    Post on X
  11. 2021

    Charity Engine for Booker and Sutherland · January

    579 falls

    A slower search through 2020, reaching |z| up to 1019 for small d, turns up 579. It finds nothing for the last seven.

    x
    143075750505019222645
    y
    −143070303858622169975
    z
    −6941531883806363291
    Post on X

After 2021

The Ponmath era

Published searches stop below |z| = 1019. Ponmath's browsers sample the band , and Robinhood Chain re-checks every share in public. Nobody knows where an answer lies, or whether one lies there at all.

  1. The hunt goes on chain

    The Ponmath contracts are deployed on Robinhood Chain, at block . From then on a share counts only if the Hunt contract redoes the math and agrees.

  2. The first share

    A browser finds a candidate that passes all nine square filters and the hash target, and the chain accepts it.

  3. Now

    Read from the chain

    The swarm so far

    Shares accepted

    Candidates checked (estimate)

    Miners

    Candidates are an estimate: the chain counts shares, and each share stands for about 225 filter survivors, times the engine's measured candidates per survivor.

Seven numbers still open

No sum of three cubes is known for any of them. Shares on each, straight from the Hunt contract's allTargets().

TargetBandSharesStateHunt

Sources: Wikipedia, Sums of three cubes; Booker, Cracking the problem with 33 (2019); Booker and Sutherland, On a question of Mordell (PNAS, 2021). Every triple on this page is checked again by your browser when you press Check it.

The next line is blank.

Seven numbers, one band, every share checked on chain. Your browser can search it.

Start hunting